The award was created in 1962 as a way to honor Ted Williams. Williams excelled in his appearances but perhaps they should have waited until Willie Mays came along. Many have stated that the All-Star Game was made for Willie Mays.
1963, 68-Willie Mays
1965-Juan Marichal
1966-Brooks Robinson
1967-Tony Perez
1971-Frank Robinson
1972-Joe Morgan
1977-Don Sutton
1981, 84-Gary Carter
1985-LaMarr Hoyt
1986-Roger Clemens
1999-Pedro Martinez


